Oreo Surprise Cookies

I saw this idea for an Oreo surprise cookie a while back.  Here is what they look like when done:

Looks pretty much like a chocolate chip cookie right??

The surprise is inside.

yummy oreo surprise cookies

That’s right, its an oreo inside a chocolate chip cookie!!

The first time I tried to make these cookies, it didn’t go so well.  I was trying to cover an oreo with chocolate chip cookie dough and it was a big sticky mess.  I ended up needing so much cookie dough to get it all covered that I could only make 5 out of a whole batch of cookie dough.  Then when they baked, they spread out and became huge flat cookies with a large lump in the middle.  So not what I was going for.

Enter the brilliant hubby.  He suggested we bake them in a muffin tin.  Genious!!

I put a scoop of cookie dough into the bottom of the muffin tin.  Then I squished it with an oreo.  I then put another scoop on the top and spread it out a little.  Make sure you spray your muffin tin first.

When they come out they look like this:

Wouldn’t know there was an oreo in there would you??

My hubbs took this to his last day of school.  {They had a potluck day since it was the end}  And everyone LOVED LOVED LOVED them!!  So if you need a new interesting pot luck idea {especially for a group of guys} try these!!  Or if you just want some yummy cookies, they don’t disappoint.

Thanks for reading!!


  1. Wow! I love this Oreo Muffins so bad… I can’t wait to try and bake this. Thanks for sharing the steps Connie…
    Bettie41 recently posted..claiming back ppiMy Profile

  2. I’ve awarded you and your amazing blog the Versatile Blogger award! I hope you can accept it – details are at http://ajennuinelife.blogspot.com/2012/02/versatile-blogger-award.html

  3. those look so good, it would be too dangerous for me to make something like that i’d end up eating them all my self!

  4. I love the OREO surprise in the middle – how fun!! I am visiting from Lil’ Luna and I’d love if you would visit back! Have a great day!


  5. These look sinfully delicious – a definite cheat day treat! Thanks for becoming a follower and I am also following you.
    Suzanne recently posted..Linky Party Follower HopMy Profile

  6. Hi Connie, thanks so much for following! I’m following right back on Linky :) xo K
    Coral and Coast recently posted..Our Kiwi Road Trip – Day ThreeMy Profile

  7. I have heard of these and wondered how you made them. They look delish! Thanks so much for following me on my blog. I am now your newest LF! :)

  8. Jeannie Marie says:

    Thanks for the follow! Following back! Love the cookies! I’ll have to pin them!

  9. I want to try these so bad! They look incredible! I am now following you back via LF and look forward to reading more of your lovely blog :)
    Erika @ My Road to Savings recently posted..Chicken Lo MeinMy Profile

  10. Yummy! My kids will love these!!

  11. Cookies look delish…following.

  12. Oh my…they look like heaven on a plate! What a great idea.

    Thanks so much for stopping by and following me via the Linky blog hop. I am now following you and look forward to reading your fabulous blog!

    Best wishes,

  13. Those cookies look so good!! Thanks for stopping by my blog, I am now following you on Linky Followers!
    Alyssa recently posted..Whet Your Appetite Wednesday {20 Donut Recipes}My Profile

  14. What a terrific idea! I’m sure my grandsons will love these at their next visit!!

  15. These do look amazing! Thanks for stopping by…I look forward to following you too!


  16. First off let me say, THANK you for following me on the new Linky party. I am SO glad you did because I came over to say HI, and LOVED the recipe you have posted and am going to make it this weekend!!!!
    I am also your NEWEST follower on Linky! :)

  17. Wow! These look yummy! THanks for visiting and following my blog! I’m happy to follow you back via linky.

  18. I found you from the C.R.A.F.T. linky party. What a great tip for making those cookies! I have been meaning to make them, so this is perfect!
    Heidi {It’s Our Pinteresting Life} recently posted..The Big CelebrationMy Profile

  19. ohhh YUM!!!! Thank you SO much for sharing this idea….. but oooh shoot I really think I need to stick to my diet blahhH! :) ps I have been thinking about you a lot because I have been reading a lot of the books that you have suggested in the past for your book club!

  20. Seriously….eeeep! I can’t wait to make these.
    I featured them on my party today!
    Lesley recently posted..Super Sweet Thursday Par-tay!My Profile

  21. Hey, do you bake these on 350 for 10 – 15 minutes like the recipes call for?

  22. This is such a brilliant idea! I bet they are yummy!
    Anji* recently posted..chocolate factory birthday partyMy Profile

  23. In addition to that, a suitably developed bike features a slacker head angle that’s
    a lot more soothing and lengthens the wheelbase, and therefore, contributes to far better operating in the bike.

    The weight loss diet for the working mother needs to
    be organized ahead of time. This is the first in a series of 6 articles on how
    to buy riding gear for your motorcycle.
    Jessica recently posted..JessicaMy Profile

Speak Your Mind


CommentLuv badge